Back to Results

The Hidden Employee Retention Risk Leaders Are Missing

Low employee turnover may give organisations a false sense of security. The article argues that many employees are staying because economic conditions limit their options rather than because they are engaged. Leaders should strengthen manager capability, recognition, flexibility and development to build genuine commitment before the labour market improves.

This article was written by Kara Dennison and published in Forbes.

At the start of 2026, the case for a Great Turnover was becoming clear. Engagement was dropping. Frustration was rising. Workers were growing more disconnected from their organizations, and the data pointed to a wave of departures the moment the right opportunity showed up.

That moment still hasn’t arrived, but the conditions driving the prediction haven’t gone away either. If anything, recent workforce data suggests they’ve gotten worse.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ March 2026 JOLTS report, the U.S. quit rate sits at 2%, near its lowest level in a decade. For many leaders, that looks like good news. Fewer people are leaving voluntarily, and turnover has held steady.

At the same time, Gallup’s 2026 workplace research found that employee engagement has fallen to 31%, its lowest level in 11 years, and long-term organizational commitment hit a nine-year low.

Those two numbers moving in opposite directions can’t both be good news. The more likely explanation is that the turnover many organizations expected hasn’t disappeared. It’s been delayed. Employees are staying put not because they feel connected to their organizations, but because leaving has become riskier and more expensive.

The danger isn’t today’s quit rate. The danger is mistaking a low quit rate for a healthy workforce. In many organizations right now, employees are staying because they feel they have to, not because they want to.

The Growing Gap Between Retention Numbers and Workforce Reality

The voluntary quit rate of 2% remains near its lowest level in a decade, and many organizations are reading it as proof that their retention efforts are working. But a low quit rate and a committed workforce are not the same thing.

Gallup found that only 31% of U.S. employees are engaged at work, the lowest level recorded in 11 years. That means nearly seven out of ten workers are showing up without being fully invested in what they do or where they work.

Globally, only 20% of employees are engaged. The other 80% are either going through the motions or actively disengaged. None of that shows up in the quit rate, and all of those workers are still on the payroll.

This is what quiet quitting looks like at scale: employees who have mentally checked out but continue to show up and do only what’s required. They’ve made a quiet calculation. Leaving isn’t worth the risk right now, but staying doesn’t mean commitment.The cost of that disengagement is measurable. Lost productivity now runs an estimated $10 trillion annually, up from $8.9 trillion the previous year. Organizations are carrying a workforce that is physically present but psychologically elsewhere, and most leaders have no idea how much it’s costing them because the number they’re watching, the quit rate, isn’t telling them any of it.

Three Reasons Most Employees Are Resentfully Staying

Before leaders can fix what’s broken, they need to understand what’s actually keeping workers in place. It isn’t loyalty. It isn’t satisfaction. And it isn’t belief in the mission. Workers are staying because leaving feels too risky, and right now, that risk is too high for most people to take.

1. The Hiring Market Has Stalled

Job openings closed 2025 at 6.5 million, the lowest in more than eight years outside the COVID collapse of 2020. U.S. employers added just 584,000 jobs in 2025, the worst year since 2009 outside the pandemic, compared to 2 million in 2024.

The labor market that powered the Great Resignation no longer exists. What replaced it is a low-hire, low-fire environment where workers aren’t staying by choice. They’re staying because there’s nowhere to go.

2. Financial Pressure Makes Leaving Unaffordable

Leaving a job means absorbing risk. For most American workers right now, that risk is financial. Resume Now’s 2026 Cost-of-Living Crunch Report found that just 12% of workers say their wages have kept pace with inflation, and only 17% feel financially secure enough to cover essentials and save.

For a workforce living that close to the edge, a gap between jobs isn’t an inconvenience. It’s a financial emergency. Staying in a job that drains them is the only option that doesn’t feel catastrophic.

Read the full article here: The Employee Retention Problem Most Leaders Are Missing